What’s a Catholic to do?

The US election this week is clearly of great importance for the world. I was searching to find a Catholic view on voting for this front page. The American Bishops’ own guidelines, entitled “Forming Consciences for Faithful Citizenship”, published last year have been accused by some of ignoring Pope Francis’s teaching. See for yourself at

I settled for this”outsider’s” piece from Fox News

“[A month ago] Pope Francis weighed into the U.S. elections Sunday, urging American Catholics struggling to choose a president to study the issues, pray and then vote your conscience. Francis was asked by reporters on the way from Azerbaijan how he would counsel the American faithful who are being asked to choose between Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump. Francis added that he would never interfere in an election campaign, saying “the people are sovereign.” “I’ll just say this: Study the proposals well, pray, and choose in conscience.”

Francis, prefacing his words by saying he was talking about a “fictional situation,” appeared to say that the U.S. was among the countries that have lost what he described as a culture of politics. “When in any country there are two, three or four candidates who don’t satisfy everyone, it means that perhaps the political life of that country has become too politicized and that it does not have much political culture,” he said. “People say ‘I’m from this party’ or ‘I’m from that party,’ but effectively, they don’t have clear thoughts about the basics, about proposals.”

Francis did intervene in the campaign earlier this year when, on his way home from a visit to the U.S. – Mexican border, he was asked about Trump’s proposal to build a wall to keep Mexicans out of the U.S. Francis said anyone who builds a wall isn’t Christian. Trump fired back, saying it was “disgraceful” for a religious leader to question someone’s faith.

Many American Catholics have been struggling to decide between the two candidates over a host of issues that makes each one unpalatable on faith-based and other grounds.”

Fr Matthew